Monday, November 20, 2006

1031 Exchange Deadlines: 45 Days and 180 Days

A successful 1031 exchange transaction requires Investors to comply with certain deadlines pursuant to Section 1031 of the Internal Revenue Code, which have been further clarified within Section 1.1031 of the Department of the Treasury Regulations.

The tax-deferred exchange deadlines consist of the 45 calendar day identification period and the 180 calendar day (or less) exchange period. These deadlines can not be extended under any circumstances, unless the President of the United States declares a natural disaster area that affects the properties or parties involved with the tax-deferred like-kind exchange transaction.

45 Calendar Day Identification Deadline

Investors completing a 1031 exchange must identify their potential replacement property(ies) to their Qualified Intermediary (Accommodator) no later than midnight of the 45th calendar day following the close of the relinquished property sale transaction. For example, if the sale of the Investor's relinquished property closed on October 31 the first day of the 45 calendar day identification period would be November 1 and the 45th calendar day deadline would be December 15th.

This deadline is exactly 45 calendar days, so if the 45th calendar day lands on a Saturday, Sunday or legal holiday, the deadline is NOT extended to the next business day as it is in other parts of the income tax code and regulations.

Investors should plan ahead once they have decided to complete a 1031 exchange transaction. The 45 calendar day identification period will arrive very quickly. Investors may wish to approach and negotiate with the buyer of their relinquished property for an extention of time to close the transaction in order to provide more time to locate and identify suitable like-kind replacement properties.

The identification should be made formally in writing to the Qualified Intermediary by facsimile, United States Mail or overnight courer such as FedEx, UPS or DHL.


Exeter 1031 Exchange Services, LLC maintains a bank of facsimile machines so that clients can submit their like-kind replacement property identification forms 24 hours a day, 365 days a year, via facsimile. Refer to our web page on Identification Requirements for Like-Kind Replacement Properties for more complete information on the identifcation process.

Investors can change their mind by formally revoking their identification of their like-kind replacement properties and subsequently submit a new identification form at anytime during their 45 calendar day identification period, but may not change their mind after this time frame has passed. Revoking and submitting a new identification form does not change or reset the original 45 calendar day identification deadline.

The act of altering, changing, amending, or back-dating a replacement property identification form in order to save a 1031 exchange transaction is classifeid as Federal tax fraud, and you should avoid any Qualified Intermediary that engages in, or permits or suggests any such practice.

Failure to identify like-kind replacement property(ies) within the 45 calendar day window will result in a failed tax-deferred like-kind exchange transaction, and the subject transaction must be recharacterized as a taxable sale rather than a tax-deferred like-kind exchange.

180 Calendar Day Exchange Period

Investors must complete their 1031 exchange, which includes the receipt of title to all of their like-kind replacement properties, no later than the earlier of:

(1) midnight of the 180th calendar day following the close of the relinquished property sale transaction, or

(2) the due date of the Federal income tax return for the tax year in which the relinquished property was sold, including any extensions of time to file.

You do not need to be concerned about part two above unless the first relinquished property transaction sold and closed within the 1031 exchange transaction closed on or after October 17th and on or before December 31st of any given tax year, which would mean that the 180th calendar day would land after April 15.

Investors that have tax-deferred exchanges closing on or after October 17th and on or before December 31th of any given income tax year will have fewer than 180 calendar days to complete their tax-deferred like-kind exchange transaction, unless they file for an extension of time to file their federal and, as necessary, state income tax returns.


Once the extensions of time have been filed, Investors must complete their tax-deferred like-kind exchange transaction within the 180 calendar days before they actually file their Federal and, if applicable, state income tax returns. Investors will never have more than 180 calendar days to complete their tax-deferred like-kind exchange transaction.

8 comments:

Anonymous said...

If I revoke my identification of property by the 45th day, is my QI allowed to retain any of the exchange funds that were going to be used to purcahse the property? For example, if my QI earmarked the exchange funds as an earnest money deposit on the replacement property, are they allowed to withhold that money and not refund it to me?

William L. Exeter said...

Hi Tina,

I'm not sure what you mean by "retain" any of your 1031 exchange funds, so I'll make a couple of comments and then you can let me know if that addresses your question.

First, a QI is required under the Section 1.1031 of the Treasury Regulations to hold all of your 1031 exchange funds until after the 45th day even if you change your mind about completing a 1031 exchange.

The QI can release the 1031 exchange funds to you on the 46th day IF after the 45th day you have not identified any property or you have fully (100%) revoked your identified properties so that technical there are no properties identified.

Likewise, a QI is required under the Section 1.1031 of the Treasury Regulations to hold all of your 1031 exchange funds until after the 180th day if you have identified potential like-kind replacement property and then decide not to complete your 1031 exchange.

The QI can release the 1031 exchange funds to you on the 180th day because the 1031 exchange period has expired.

A QI can never retain your 1031 exchange funds as a penalty. They must refund it when the Treasury Regulations permit.

Unknown said...

Thanks William,

Instead of making an actual earnest money payment, the QI just made a note that exchange funds were marked for an earnest money payment on my replacement property. They are telling me that even if I revoke 100% of the replacement property, that they can hold on to the funds that were marked for an earnest money payment. I do not agree and think that they have to return all of my money. Do you know exactly what part of the regulations state that they have to return all of the money? I have looked and am not seeing it specifically addressed. Thank you so much for your help.

William L. Exeter said...

Hi Tina,

The Treasury Regulations do not specifically state that they have to return all of your funds to you. The Treasury Regulations only state that they can not return any of the funds until certain events or deadlines have occurred.

Is the QI stating they will keep the funds for ever or just until the 45th day?

They technically should not be releasing any funds until after the 45th day, but if they are telling you they must hold them forever I am dumbfounded.

Unknown said...

William,

Thank you so much for your help. They are saying they will hold it until a dispute over the entitlement to the earnest money is decided. The exchange agreement clearly says that the QI will not be bound by other agreements. However, the QI insists that they can hold a portion of my exchange funds until a dispute over my real estate contract is decided. I don't see how a QI can hold exchange funds until a matter not involving the QI is resolved.

Tina

William L. Exeter said...

Hi Tina,

A legal dispute is a different issue because the QI has been assigned into the contract, which means the QI is now a party to the contract and is technically the buyer, and although the contract says that the QI is not liable for other contracts that agreement is between you and the QI and not between the QI and the Seller. The QI is involved in the matter whether they like it or not because they have been assigned into to transaction and are acting as the principal going forward.

The problem is that if the QI releases the funds to you and the Seller prevails and is deemed to be able to recover the earnest money deposit from the QI the QI may have to pay it to the Seller and then request it from you under the QI contract language. The QI does not want to expose themself to any liability or financial loss and are probably within their rights to protect themselves (depending on the contact language).

This is a tough spot to be in, but the QI is probably correct in holding the funds until the legal issue is resolved.

Unknown said...

Thanks William.

I agree with your assessment if the contract had actually been assigned; however, no assignment took place. Sorry that I did not make that clear. My QI doesn't assign until right before closing. My 45 days ended almost a month before the scheduled closing date. This is why I am so confused. If the QI is not a party to my real estate contract because it was never assigned, it doesn't seem like they should have any right to refuse to return all the exchange funds to me. Again, the exchange document says that the QI shall not be bound by any other contract.

William L. Exeter said...

Hi Tina,

In that case, then I can not think of any reason they are holding your funds except that they are paranoid.

You have completely revoked your identification prior to the 45 day deadline, and you are now past your 45 day deadline so that you can not identify any other property, and the QI never assigned into the transaction to begin with, so the 1031 exchange has failed and any dispute between you and the seller should not affect the QI. They should refund your funds immediately. Have they given you any explanation as to why they will not return your funds beyond the dispute? Have they explain exactly how they think they are liable since they have not assigned into the contract?